Interactivity is one of those words which can mean everything and nothing at once. So in corralling this naughty concept, my aim is to try to understand it in its most general sense, but also to identify those very particular aspects of interactivity which are relevant to "games and stories.
So there's an adequate common-sense definition. But if we're triangulating our concept of narrative with this concept of interactivity, the problem is that by this definition all forms of narrative end up being interactive. For example, take this book you're holding. Can you really say that the experience of reading it isn't interactive? Aren't you holding the book and physically turning the pages? Aren't you emotionally and psychologically immersed?
Aren't you cognitively engaging with language itself to decode the signs of the text? And doesn't the physical form of the book and your understanding of its contents evolve as you interact with it? Yes and no. If what we're after is relationships between our terms, it's important to find the terrain of overlap between narrative and interactivity. But we don't want the two terms to be identical. It seems important to be able to say that some narratives are interactive and some are not -- or rather, that perhaps all narratives can be interactive, but they can be interactive in different ways.
Intuitively, there is in fact some kind of difference between a typical linear book and a choose-your-own-adventure book. And it seems that the difference in some way is that naughty concept of interactivity. Here's one solution. Instead of understanding "interactivity" as a singular phenomenon, let's subdivide it into the various ways it can be paired up with a narrative experience. Four modes of narrative interactivity are presented:. Mode 1: Cognitive Interactivity; or Interpretive Participation with a Text This is the psychological, emotional, hermeneutic, semiotic, reader-response, Rashomon -effect-ish, etc.
Example: you reread a book after several years have passed and you find it's completely different than the book you remember. Mode 2: Functional Interactivity; or Utilitarian Participation with a Text Included here: functional, structural interactions with the material textual apparatus. That book you reread: did it have a table of contents? An index? What was the graphic design of the pages? How thick was the paper stock? How large was the book? How heavy? All of these characteristics are part of the total experience of reading interaction.
Mode 3: Explicit Interactivity; or Participation with Designed Choices and Procedures in a Text This is "interaction" in the obvious sense of the word: overt participation such as clicking the nonlinear links of a hypertext novel, following the rules of a Surrealist language game, rearranging the clothing on a set of paper dolls. Included here: choices, random events, dynamic simulations, and other procedures programmed into the interactive experience.
Mode 4: Meta-interactivity; or Cultural Participation with a Text This is interaction outside the experience of a single text. The clearest examples come from fan culture, in which readers appropriate, deconstruct, and reconstruct linear media, participating in and propagating massive communal narrative worlds.
These four modes of narrative interactivity cognitive, functional, explicit, and cultural are not four distinct categories, but four overlapping flavors of participation that occur to varying degrees in all media experience. Most interactive activities incorporate some or all of them simultaneously. So, what we normally think of as "interactive," what separates the book from the choose-your-own-adventure, is category number three: explicit interactivity. As we hone in on our four terms, note that we've made enough progress to already identify those phenomena we might call "interactive narratives.
Are games interactive narratives in this sense? The choices and decisions that game players make certainly constitute very explicit interactivity. We're getting closer to games.
Heterotopia & Play – First Person Scholar
But first: play. Perhaps more than any other one of the four concepts, play is used in so many contexts and in so many different ways that it's going to be a real struggle to make it play nice with our other terms. We play games. We play with toys. We play musical instruments and we play the radio. We can make a play on words, be playful during sex, or simply be in a playful state of mind. What do all of those meanings have to do with narrative and interactivity? Before jumping into a definition of play, first let's try to categorize all of these diverse play phenomena.
We can put them into three general categories. Category 1: Game Play, or the Formal Play of Games This is the focused kind of play that occurs when one or more players plays a game, whether it is a board game, card game, sport, computer game, etc. What exactly is a game? We're getting to that soon. Category 2: Ludic Activities, or Informal Play This category includes all of those nongame behaviors that we also think of as "playing:" dogs chasing each other, two college students tossing a frisbee back and forth, a circle of children playing ring-around-the-rosy, etc.
Ludic activities are quite similar to games, but generally less formalized. Category 3: Being Playful, or Being in a Play State of Mind This broad category includes all of the ways we can "be playful" in the context of other activities. Being in a play state of mind does not necessarily mean that you are playing -- but rather that you are injecting a spirit of play into some other action.
For example, it is one thing to insult a friend's appearance, but it is another thing entirely if the insult is delivered playfully.
- In-Vivo Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy III: In-Vivo MR Spectroscopy: Potential and Limitations: 2 (NMR Basic Principles and Progress)!
- A Dog In The Night!
- Why Violent Video Games Should not Be Banned - Argumentative Essay on Debate Topic;
- Take a Break Self-Meditate: Meditations to Soothe Your Soul & Lift Your Spirit.
A quick structural note -- the latter categories contain the earlier ones. Game play 1 is a particular kind of ludic activity 2 and ludic activities 2 are a particular way of being playful 3. But what overarching definition could we possibly give to the word "play" that would address all of these uses?
Shop with confidence
Play is the free space of movement within a more rigid structure. Play exists both because of and also despite the more rigid structures of a system.
- Brain Mnemonics: Memorize the Parts of the Brain in Minutes!
- Le livre des destins T01 : Le premier pas (French Edition)!
- Manual Terms of Play: Essays on Words That Matter in Videogame Theory.
- Post Comment.
- Lay Lady Lay (The Detective Macaulay Murders Trilogy Book 2).
- Fighting Terror: Ethical Dilemmas!
That sounds quite abstract and obtuse for a fun-loving word like "play," doesn't it? But it is actually quite handy. This definition of play is about relationships between the elements of a system. Think about the use of the word "play" when we talk about the "free play" of a steering wheel. The free play is the amount of movement that the steering wheel can turn before it begins to affect the tires of the car.
The play itself exists only because of the more utilitarian structures of the driving-system: the drive shaft, axles, wheels, etc. But even though the play only occurs because of these structures, the play is also exactly that thing that exists despite the system, the free movement within it, in the interstitial spaces between and among its components.
Play exists in opposition to the structures it inhabits, at odds with the utilitarian functioning of the system. Yet play is at the same time an expression of a system, and intrinsically a part of it. This definition of play does in fact cover all three kinds that we mentioned previously. Playing Chutes and Ladders occurs only because of the rigid rules of the game -- but the gameplay itself is a kind of dance of fate which occurs somewhere among the dice, pieces, board, and game players. Playing a musical instrument means manipulating within the free space of audio possibilities that the structure of the instrument was designed to engender.
Being playful in a conversation means playing in and among the linguistic and social structures that constitute the conversational context. Play can manifest in a dizzying variety of forms, from intellectual and physical play to semiotic and cultural play. One way to link this understanding of play to narrative and interactivity is to consider the play of an explicitly interactive narrative.
The challenge for the creator of an interactive narrative is to design the potential for play into the structure of the experience, whether that experience is a physical object, a computer program, an inhabited space, or a set of behaviors. And the real trick is that the designed structure can guide and engender play, but never completely script it in advance. If the interaction is completely predetermined, there's no room for play in the system.
The author of a choose-your-own-adventure creates the structure that the reader inhabits, but the play emerges out of that system as the reader navigates through it. Even if the reader breaks the structure by cheating and skipping ahead, that is merely another form of play within the designed system. We have arrived at our fourth and final term: games.
With this concept, we have a new kind of naughtiness. Play, interactivity, and narrative threatened us with overinclusion.
moahoonarenra.ga My approach with this concept is to define it as narrowly as possible so that we can understand what separates the play of games from other kinds of ludic activities. We are, after all, looking at games and stories, not play and stories. The fact that games are a formal kind of play was referenced before. But how exactly is that formality manifest?
Here is a definition that separates games from other forms of play:. A game is a voluntary interactive activity, in which one or more players follow rules that constrain their behavior, enacting an artificial conflict that ends in a quantifiable outcome. Voluntary If you're forced against your will to play a game, you're not really playing. Games are voluntary activities. Interactive Remember this word? It's referencing our third mode of interactivity: explicit participation.
Behavior-Constraining Rules All games have rules.